Milk

my rating: 4 out of 5

Harvey Milk was extraordinary in so many ways. Of course, I had no idea who he was until this film came out. According to Milk, he always somehow intuitively knew he would die for his cause. He seemed to know that he would become a martyr, a quirky historic figure, and that's how he lived. He seemed brave, intelligent, funny, and admirable.

There was no one better than Sean Penn to play this role. Everyone knows that Mr. Penn is very outspoken about politics in his life. That's putting it nicely, too. I guess another way to say it is: the guy is pretty much a nut job. I've seen some interviews of Sean Penn that flat out frightened me. I know that his politics play a big part in his decision to play the part of Harvey Milk. But, it is such a stellar performance that you never once feel that you are watching "actor Sean Penn." Instead, you get totally invested in this "Harvey Milk" guy. It is a wonderful performance for which Penn deserved the Oscar. (that he won)

The writing and the story are just incredible. The quality is so good. Like many films directed by Gus Van Sant, it has a richness to it that can't be faked. It is just as good as he's ever been as a director, if not better now that he's a seasoned veteran. There are just so many good elements coming together here, and they are all expertly blended by Van Sant. That's the mark of a good director. Because of his direction, Milk is neither dry nor pandering.

Obviously, kids should not see this movie. Even as an adult, I hesitate to recommend it because it is certainly one-sided. There are many scenes that are inappropriate. But, it shows the perspective of an interesting and influential recently historic figure. And, the fact that it is based on a true story makes it that much better. It all makes for one very, very deeply provoking and memorable movie.